Faith Erin Hicks, Girl Reporter ([info]smuu) wrote,

Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of WTF?

Well, I'm in Ontario, and have already done a few of my pilgrimage rites: caught up on sleep, went to the art store, drove by Sheridan and gave it the finger, and saw Indiana Jones last night. I left the theatre feeling very mixed and not quite sure what to feel... Nonetheless, here is my quick and dirty review (spoilers ahoy):

Despite the movie's flaws, the beginning was magnificent. When the mean n' nasty Soviets dragged Junior from the trunk of their car and he picked up his hat and then we saw him, yes, he was old, but he was still Indy, still our Dr. Jones, and I felt my heart swelling with movie-love for this iconic character. And in the beginning all was well, and the movie seemed more to be a meditation on the aging of magnificent human beings who've had magnificent lives, and how even though they can defeat Nazis and save the world again and again ... well, we all end up as worm food. It was fine with me that Indy was old (as was Harrison Ford, and Steven Spielberg, and George Lucas), and I was glad they weren't pretending this was 1936 and Indy was as ageless and as transferable as James Bond. The world was passing Indy (and Harrison, and Steven and George) by, and belonged (and belongs) now to Shia LeBoeuf ... but maybe that's not a bad thing, since he seemed so attentive to what these old coots could teach him. He washed the stink of Michael Bay and Transformers off, and emerged the other side a nice looking kid, maybe with a bit of his dad's wild side (yes, of course he was Indy's son, and the best exchange in the entire movie had to do with not-clued-in-yet Indy telling his dropout son that it was fine Mutt wasn't in school ... only to have Indy completely change his tune once he found out Mutt was his kid. I found that quite enduring, especially after having just seen The Last Crusade. You shouldn't be so hard on your Dad, Indy).

So it was good, and it was fine and I was so happy that the movie was gelling and that I liked that Harrison Ford was old and then ... it all went to hell. I don't quite know why. I know that Indy is a homage to the B-movies of old, but for some reason, the Macguffin, which lead to a convoluted plot about aliens on earth, rang wrong to me. Indiana Jones vs. Aliens? I don't know why it made me squirm. All three movies had gods (or God) in them, so why should a different god (an outer space god) seem so ... well, gross? I don't know. Maybe because it reminded me too much of The X-Files? Or because it wasn't about a supernatural being or a god at all, but rather a technologically advanced race from "the space between worlds"? It came off like a ripoff of the weakest Tintin book, Flight 714.

I was also troubled by the fact that despite Spielberg's insistence that he was going old skool, and lightening up on the CG, the movie had the unnecessary glossy sheen of something sent through the ILM wringer. Why were there CG monkeys? Why were there CG gophers? The creepy crawly ants (during our patented Indy-gross-out-sequence) didn't have the tactile feel of the snakes, bugs or rats of the previous movies, and I didn't feel the actors' squirmy "I don't want to be here!" energy. I missed that.

So of course it wasn't brilliant, of course it fell short. But at least there were those lovely first 40 minutes ... I don't know who to blame for the last hour, but I'm sure I'll find someone to point my finger at. Why is it that I instantly want to blame Lucas and not Spielberg? That's probably incredibly unfair.

Oh, and the preview for FRANK MILLER PRESENTS FRANK MILLER'S THE SPIRIT DIRECTED BY FRANK MILLER ran in front of the movie, and it's even more terrible on the big screen than it was on YouTube. I will take a thousand Indy vs. Aliens movies before I watch that load of crap.

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 13 comments

[info]the_big_mo

May 23 2008, 16:41:49 UTC 3 years ago

I'd say it will greatly improve upon a second viewing. The alien skull plot, while probably the most convoluted of the films, seemed to really fall in step with the rest of the films the more I thought about it. I mean, what better way to marry archeology with the 50's sci-fi stuff that Spielberg and Lucas wanted to play around with this time?

There were a couple of touchy points, sure, but it all really felt right to me. That first hour was pretty stellar, though.

And the Spirit trailer make me feel all stabby. Gr.

[info]smuu

May 26 2008, 16:09:16 UTC 3 years ago

Yes, "stabby." That is a good way of putting it... :P I think I will see Indy a second time, and maybe with the shock of knowing the alien subplot over with, will enjoy it more. We'll see.

[info]nem0

May 23 2008, 17:13:38 UTC 3 years ago

I've been waiting for your review. My parents are huge Indy fans, but they were getting a little concerned after hearing that professional reviews were mixed. (Of course, it doesn't matter that much, because we're seeing it anyway, reviews be damned.)

The plot kind of sounds like something from the Marathon/Pathways Into Darkness mythos, what with the ancient aliens hidden in the jungle and all. It does smack of X-Files* (boo), but I guess I'll reserve judgment until I've seen it.

*Have you seen the bits from the new X-Files movie? WTMF? I am so conflicted about it. I mean, it could be good, but nothing after the first X-Files movie was good, and Chris Carter's storytelling has issues.

[info]smuu

May 26 2008, 16:10:06 UTC 3 years ago

I was so burned by the end of the series, I just can't see myself enjoying the movie. :P Maybe if it gets really good reviews I'll go but ... twice shy, y'know? It was the first TV show I ever loved, and we had the biggest breakup ever.

[info]salthegeek

May 23 2008, 17:52:49 UTC 3 years ago

i still dont know what to think about it
i really liked it , but there were allot of in-jokes to film history scattered around the movie .
i guess it a movie for filmmakers and film geeks

[info]jillithe

May 23 2008, 20:32:40 UTC 3 years ago

I got a bit squirmy in the very first minute due to that first CG gopher. Why? why? And the monkeys? The guy sitting next to me was practically in tears when they started with the monkeys and the vine-swinging. Sigh. I wish I could have loved this.

[info]rashomonchb

May 23 2008, 21:19:52 UTC 3 years ago

At the end when Indy was all "I bet my father is laughing right now" line plays, I wanted an inserted voice over of the SNL Sean Connery going "HAHAHAHAHA, I slept with your mother Trebeck".

[info]silver_rabbit

May 24 2008, 02:24:46 UTC 3 years ago

I've got mixed feelings about this one too. I think I would have loved it when I was ten. I did love Kate Blanchett as a kickass villianess, and my mom loved that Marion came back and she was (gasp!) an older woman love interest. So it gets points for cool girls. Mutt was cute too.

[info]smuu

May 26 2008, 16:11:05 UTC 3 years ago

Yeah, it felt very much like it was less than the sum of its parts. Good bits and stuff, but perhaps not a great whole.

Anonymous

May 24 2008, 13:51:41 UTC 3 years ago

Wow, your feelings on the flick mirror mine pretty directly... Great first act, and then it just fell apart. It's a pretty dismal movie. Poor Indy! His best days are behind him.

- Tederick

[info]thedigitalangel

May 24 2008, 14:42:11 UTC 3 years ago

You know what really killed me about the aliens? The fact that the prop head looked like plastic with plastic wrap stuffed inside.

I didn't think it was terrible, but it certainly felt half-assed, like Spielberg owed Lucas a favor or something.

Anonymous

May 25 2008, 19:40:15 UTC 3 years ago

Grr. Arrgh

I usually just lurk to watch for updates to Ice or announcements of new comics (got ZC! can't wait for the boarding school one!) but I just saw Indy 4 last night and the wounds are too fresh not to rant.

It's not that Indy fought aliens. After all, that would have been right in the old-school serial wheelhouse. It was that he DIDN'T fight aliens, that the aliens were these noble serene enlightened creatures - straight out of the EIGHTIES New-Agey sci fi movement.

Everything that's wrong with the movie can be summed up in the tomb scene: All the other Indiana Jones movies had a such a respect for their antiquities, for the feel of hidden power within something as simple as a wooden cup, a rock with three lines, a ark full of sand. This one, Indy just grabs the skull from the wrappings and hoists it up like it's the piece of plexiglass that it looks like. He doesn't treat it like anything special - and neither does the audience.

BTW, I work for a company in LA that's done some work on The Spirit, so we have a poster up. Literally half the people who walk by glance at it and say "Sin City Two?" To which I usually reply, "Yes."

Sarah

[info]smuu

May 26 2008, 16:12:35 UTC 3 years ago

Re: Grr. Arrgh

Yeah, exactly. I took one look at that plastic skull and the way it was being tossed around and ... just NO. It needed to have weight and heft, both physically and in the way it was treated by the characters. It came off like a security blanket for crazy ol' John Hurt.
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…